Content hub
Leadership

SPEAKERS

No items found.
November 19, 2026

A New Role. An Old Playbook?

Will what worked before work this time?

Carina Price
|
Articles
|
November 19, 2026
Share
No items found.

Looking back over my career, I can see that I progressed into new roles without necessarily changing how I approached them.

I took with me the skills, knowledge and behaviours that had made me successful, assuming they would serve me equally well elsewhere.

Sometimes they did. Sometimes they were precisely what got in the way.

I started professional life as a lawyer in New Zealand, working in criminal and civil litigation before moving into corporate leadership, organisational change and eventually running my own business.

As a lawyer, I relied on expertise, analysis and finding answers. I was comfortable with the known, having a view and making decisions. I was the expert.

These capabilities served me well. But in broader leadership roles, having the answers wasn't always what was needed, even when I thought I knew them (which often wasn't the case!).

I needed to listen not solve, influence not direct, and allow others to find their own way.

I didn't find this easy.

Under pressure, I returned to what I knew. Looking back, I can see how behaviours that established my credibility also limited my effectiveness as a leader and my ability to develop relationships.

I had changed roles without necessarily changing how I approached them.

We appoint leaders because of what they've achieved. But what made us successful previously may not be what is needed now.

The job we think we've accepted

A new appointment usually follows conversations about responsibilities, expectations and what success might look like. We leave believing we understand the job.

But does our understanding match that of our new line manager, or indeed the wider organisation?

Perhaps we've been recruited to transform a function, while our manager prioritises stability. We arrive ready to make changes, only to discover little appetite for disruption.

Or we're expected to deliver ambitious outcomes without the authority or resources needed.

Both parties may believe they've been perfectly clear.

The difficulty isn't always that expectations haven't been discussed. It's that we've understood them differently.

We inherit more than a job

We join an established system of relationships, histories, loyalties and competing priorities. There are unwritten rules, influential relationships and maybe a few sacred cows nobody mentioned during recruitment.

We may arrive knowing what we want to change without understanding why things work as they do.

How are decisions made? Where does influence sit? Whose support do we need?

I remember bringing the directness and willingness to challenge that had served me well as a lawyer into corporate leadership. What I saw as robust discussion wasn't necessarily experienced that way by others. It took me some time to recognise that.

Or perhaps we're accustomed to autonomy, while our new manager expects greater involvement.

The question is not simply how this organisation works, but how am I engaging with it? Am I contributing to the dynamics I'm experiencing, and what might I do differently?

That doesn't mean abandoning our values or simply conforming. It means recognising that how we engage can influence what happens next.

The pressure to make an impact

We want to demonstrate that the organisation made the right decision. We want to hit the ground running, establish credibility and be seen to deliver.

So we get busy.

But what if the new role requires us to think differently about where we add value, rather than simply doing more of what we've usually done?

Perhaps our previous success came from solving problems and delivering results. Now we may need to step away from the detail, think strategically and create the conditions for others to succeed.

That can be uncomfortable when our sense of value is tied to what we personally deliver.

I recognise this. Learning to slow down, invite different perspectives, become comfortable with not knowing and exercise influence without direct control wasn't easy. It challenged my understanding of what made me valuable as a leader.

I didn't always recognise when I was falling back into familiar patterns. Often, it was only afterwards that I could see how my need to contribute, solve or move things forward had shaped my response.

Under pressure, we can default to the very behaviours we might need to change.

Perhaps we need to resist the urge to demonstrate immediate impact and consider what we're trying to cause through our leadership.

What do we want to be different because we're here? What relationships do we need to develop? What must we understand before deciding what to change?

This isn't about delaying necessary action. It's about being intentional.

The difference between intention and impact

We may believe we're being decisive, while others feel we're being rash and steamrolling them.

We may believe we're giving autonomy, while they feel we've left them to fend for themselves.

Our intentions and our impact aren't necessarily the same.

Without feedback, we may never recognise the difference.

This has been an important part of my own learning. Being clear about what I intended didn't necessarily mean I understood how others were experiencing me.

Perhaps our first few months should involve as much curiosity about ourselves and our relationships within the new context as about delivering results.

How are others experiencing me? What am I contributing to the dynamics around me? What might I experiment with doing differently?

A different kind of transition plan

We're often encouraged to develop a plan for our first 100 days.

That makes sense. But what about a plan for how we might need to develop ourselves as leaders?

Alongside understanding the business, setting priorities and delivering results, we need opportunities to step back, seek feedback and question our assumptions about what this new role requires of us.

I wonder how differently I might have approached some of my own transitions had I been more curious, not only about the role and the organisation, but about what I was bringing with me and what I might need to leave behind.

Getting the job is recognition of what we've already achieved. Succeeding in it may depend on our willingness to notice, question and respond differently.

Share

SPEAKERS

No items found.

Looking back over my career, I can see that I progressed into new roles without necessarily changing how I approached them.

I took with me the skills, knowledge and behaviours that had made me successful, assuming they would serve me equally well elsewhere.

Sometimes they did. Sometimes they were precisely what got in the way.

I started professional life as a lawyer in New Zealand, working in criminal and civil litigation before moving into corporate leadership, organisational change and eventually running my own business.

As a lawyer, I relied on expertise, analysis and finding answers. I was comfortable with the known, having a view and making decisions. I was the expert.

These capabilities served me well. But in broader leadership roles, having the answers wasn't always what was needed, even when I thought I knew them (which often wasn't the case!).

I needed to listen not solve, influence not direct, and allow others to find their own way.

I didn't find this easy.

Under pressure, I returned to what I knew. Looking back, I can see how behaviours that established my credibility also limited my effectiveness as a leader and my ability to develop relationships.

I had changed roles without necessarily changing how I approached them.

We appoint leaders because of what they've achieved. But what made us successful previously may not be what is needed now.

The job we think we've accepted

A new appointment usually follows conversations about responsibilities, expectations and what success might look like. We leave believing we understand the job.

But does our understanding match that of our new line manager, or indeed the wider organisation?

Perhaps we've been recruited to transform a function, while our manager prioritises stability. We arrive ready to make changes, only to discover little appetite for disruption.

Or we're expected to deliver ambitious outcomes without the authority or resources needed.

Both parties may believe they've been perfectly clear.

The difficulty isn't always that expectations haven't been discussed. It's that we've understood them differently.

We inherit more than a job

We join an established system of relationships, histories, loyalties and competing priorities. There are unwritten rules, influential relationships and maybe a few sacred cows nobody mentioned during recruitment.

We may arrive knowing what we want to change without understanding why things work as they do.

How are decisions made? Where does influence sit? Whose support do we need?

I remember bringing the directness and willingness to challenge that had served me well as a lawyer into corporate leadership. What I saw as robust discussion wasn't necessarily experienced that way by others. It took me some time to recognise that.

Or perhaps we're accustomed to autonomy, while our new manager expects greater involvement.

The question is not simply how this organisation works, but how am I engaging with it? Am I contributing to the dynamics I'm experiencing, and what might I do differently?

That doesn't mean abandoning our values or simply conforming. It means recognising that how we engage can influence what happens next.

The pressure to make an impact

We want to demonstrate that the organisation made the right decision. We want to hit the ground running, establish credibility and be seen to deliver.

So we get busy.

But what if the new role requires us to think differently about where we add value, rather than simply doing more of what we've usually done?

Perhaps our previous success came from solving problems and delivering results. Now we may need to step away from the detail, think strategically and create the conditions for others to succeed.

That can be uncomfortable when our sense of value is tied to what we personally deliver.

I recognise this. Learning to slow down, invite different perspectives, become comfortable with not knowing and exercise influence without direct control wasn't easy. It challenged my understanding of what made me valuable as a leader.

I didn't always recognise when I was falling back into familiar patterns. Often, it was only afterwards that I could see how my need to contribute, solve or move things forward had shaped my response.

Under pressure, we can default to the very behaviours we might need to change.

Perhaps we need to resist the urge to demonstrate immediate impact and consider what we're trying to cause through our leadership.

What do we want to be different because we're here? What relationships do we need to develop? What must we understand before deciding what to change?

This isn't about delaying necessary action. It's about being intentional.

The difference between intention and impact

We may believe we're being decisive, while others feel we're being rash and steamrolling them.

We may believe we're giving autonomy, while they feel we've left them to fend for themselves.

Our intentions and our impact aren't necessarily the same.

Without feedback, we may never recognise the difference.

This has been an important part of my own learning. Being clear about what I intended didn't necessarily mean I understood how others were experiencing me.

Perhaps our first few months should involve as much curiosity about ourselves and our relationships within the new context as about delivering results.

How are others experiencing me? What am I contributing to the dynamics around me? What might I experiment with doing differently?

A different kind of transition plan

We're often encouraged to develop a plan for our first 100 days.

That makes sense. But what about a plan for how we might need to develop ourselves as leaders?

Alongside understanding the business, setting priorities and delivering results, we need opportunities to step back, seek feedback and question our assumptions about what this new role requires of us.

I wonder how differently I might have approached some of my own transitions had I been more curious, not only about the role and the organisation, but about what I was bringing with me and what I might need to leave behind.

Getting the job is recognition of what we've already achieved. Succeeding in it may depend on our willingness to notice, question and respond differently.

See full transcript

About the author

Carina Price

Carina brings together a background in law, international business and organisational change with a deep understanding of the psychological dynamics that influence how people think, behave and lead.

Drawing on her extensive study of Transactional Analysis, psychotherapy and organisational change, Carina is particularly interested in the patterns of thinking and behaviour that shape how people experience themselves and their relationships with others. She recognises that these patterns often develop for good reasons, but can become less helpful as circumstances, responsibilities and expectations change.

Her coaching combines psychological depth with warmth, curiosity and thoughtful challenge. She helps individuals explore the assumptions and habitual responses that may be influencing their leadership, creating space for greater self-awareness, different perspectives and more conscious choices. Carina holds an LLB from the University of Otago, has undertaken further studies in alternative dispute resolution and Transactional Analysis, and is a Prosci Certified Change Management Practitioner. She also holds coaching accreditations for individuals and groups.

All articles by
Carina Price

Get more of this

The latest thinking, straight to your inbox